There are times when you want a crusty baguette to dip into olive oil or smear with tapenade. And then there are times when all you want is bread soft as a mother’s touch: a slice of squishy sandwich bread or ultra-soft pull-apart rolls. What makes bread tender rather than chewy?  

Loaf of white sandwich bread sliced on a table, two slices spread with peanut butter and jelly Photography and food styling by Liz Neily
White Sandwich Bread gets an extra measure of softness from potato flour.

Usually it’s gluten (a product of the protein in flour) that determines bread’s texture. Bread where gluten plays a prominent role will be chewier. When the gluten level is lower, or when gluten is tamed by the addition of “softeners” like milk, butter, eggs, or oil, the bread will be more tender.  

But sometimes another element comes into play: starch. The higher the starch level in your bread dough, the more tender your resulting bread will be. And a great way to add starch to your bread is in the form of potatoes: cooked and mashed; dried (in the form of potato flour or flakes); or even simply by using the water in which you’ve boiled potatoes.

It’s all about the starch 

Starch is a natural component of some vegetables, almost all grains (and therefore flours), and selected fruits. One of starch’s compelling properties is its ability to absorb and retain lots of liquid (just as it does in recipes using a cooked flour, like tangzhong). 

The ubiquitous potato (including sweet potatoes and yams) is one of the starchiest vegetables out there. So when you add potato to your bread dough you’re upping the dough’s starch content, effectively increasing the resulting loaf’s total liquid retention — which translates to bread with soft, moist texture and a long shelf life.

How do you make potato bread? 

The failproof way is to use a recipe that calls for potato, either cooked or dried. But you can also retrofit existing recipes to add potato. Let’s see how it’s done.  

Amish Dinner Rolls, one on a plate, more in a pretty stoneware bowl behind Photography and food styling by Liz Neily
These Amish Dinner Rolls, enhanced with mashed potato in the dough, are a Thanksgiving favorite.

Mashed potato 

Holiday favorite Amish Dinner Rolls and Sweet Potato Rolls are a fine showcase for mashed potato, either freshly made or left over from a meal. I highly recommend you try either of these, not just because they’re super-tasty but because they’ll give you an idea of what a “good” mashed potato dough should feel like: soft and tacky but not ultra-sticky.  

If you want to add mashed potato to your own favorite recipe, here’s how to do it: Add up to 1/4 cup (53g) mashed potato per cup of flour (120g) in the recipe. Reduce the main liquid (milk or water) in the recipe by 50% and mix the dough. If it seems dry and reluctant to come together, knead in more liquid as necessary to make a soft dough. If your leftover mashed potatoes have been salted, reduce the salt in your recipe by a pinch. 

For best, smoothest texture, sieve cooked potato through a ricer rather than mashing.

Tip: Make sure your potatoes are as smooth and lump-free as possible. Putting cooked potatoes through a ricer, rather than mashing them, will yield ultra-smooth dough and prevent bits of unmashed potato from creeping into your loaf. 

Cranberry Orange Holiday Bread shaped in a wreath, drizzled with white sugar glazee. Photography by Erica Allen; food styling by Liz Neily
Cranberry Orange Holiday Bread stays nice and soft thanks to the addition of potato flour.

Potato flour or potato flakes (instant mashed potatoes) 

By far the easiest way to add potato to your bread is by using potatoes in their dried form: flour or flakes, which are completely interchangeable. Since dried potato includes all the starch but none of the potato’s liquid, it won’t mess with your dough’s hydration. 

Potato flour is whole peeled potatoes that have been cooked, dried, and ground into a cream-colored powder. Potato flakes are prepared almost the same way; they’re dried differently to create flakes rather than powder. If you use potato flakes, be sure to choose unseasoned ones.

Flour-dusted rosemary potato rolls on a tray set on a table. Photography by Kristin Teig; food styling by Liz Neily
Despite their crusty-chewy appearance, these Rosemary Potato Rolls are actually delightfully soft.

When you’re first experimenting with potato flour or flakes, use a recipe that specifically calls for them. We offer an impressive selection of yeast recipes using potato flour on our recipe site, including classic Parker House Rolls, flavorful Rosemary Potato Rolls, and festive Cranberry Orange Holiday Bread, plus many more

Two clear glass cylinders, one with potato flour, one with potato flakes PJ Hamel
When substituting potato flakes for potato flour or vice versa (and measuring by volume), understand that potato flakes (right) are twice the volume of potato flour (left).

To add potato flour or flakes to an existing recipe that doesn’t call for it: Substitute 1/4 cup (46g) potato flour or 1/2 cup (43g) potato flakes for 1/4 cup (30g) of the all-purpose or bread flour in a recipe using 3 to 4 cups (360g to 480g) of flour. To prevent any potential lumps, whisk the potato flour or flakes into the recipe’s flour before adding any liquid. 

Loaf of golden potato sandwich bread, sliced, some slices layered with apple slices, blue cheese, and nuts Photography and food styling by Liz Neily
Looking for a versatile toasting and sandwich bread? This golden Potato Bread is a happy choice.

Potato water 

Potato water is water in which you’ve cooked potatoes; it includes the starch that leached out of the potatoes as they boiled. While it won’t add nearly as much starch (and therefore softness) to your bread as cooked potato or potato flour/flakes, potato water is an easy 1:1 substitute for the water or milk in any soft bread or roll recipe. Next time you boil potatoes, save some of the water and use it in these tried-and-true recipes: Sue’s Favorite Potato Rolls, Potato Bread, or Soft Dinner Rolls

Jar of potato water PJ Hamel
This water drained off boiled potatoes is cloudy thanks to starch leached from the potatoes. It'll make great bread!

Tip: Pasta water is another starch-filled liquid perfect for bread-baking. If your pasta or potato water has been salted, reduce the salt in your bread recipe a bit.  

With holiday baking looming ever closer, we all need help with time management. To get a jump start on your dinner rolls, see Freeze and bake rolls

Cover photo and food styling (Sour Cream & Chive Potato Bread or Rolls) by Liz Neily. 

Jump to Comments
Amish Dinner Rolls
Amish Dinner Rolls
4.8 out of 5 stars 505 Reviews
Total
3 hrs 35 mins
Yield
16 to 24 rolls
A headshot of PJ Hamel and her dogs
The Author

About PJ Hamel

PJ Hamel grew up in New England, graduated from Brown University, and was an award-winning Maine journalist (favorite topics: sports and food) before joining King Arthur Flour in 1990. Hired to write the newly launched Baker’s Catalogue, PJ became the small but growing company’s sixth employee.    ...
View all by PJ Hamel