Vanilla Frozen Yogurt

Recipe by PJ Hamel

Get out your ice cream maker — it's time to make your own frozen yogurt, which is far removed from what you'd buy at the store. Tangy-sweet and super-creamy, it can be flavored to taste with vanilla (of course), other flavors (butter rum? maple?), or with your favorite fruits.

Prep
5 mins
Total
1 day 25 mins
Yield
about 1 quart
Vanilla Frozen Yogurt

Instructions

Prevent your screen from going dark as you follow along.
  1. Put the yogurt into a yogurt drainer or divide it among several paper coffee filters set into a strainer or attached to the top of cups with rubber bands.

  2. Put the yogurt in the refrigerator, covered, and let it drain for 24 hours; you'll end up with about 2 cups of thick yogurt. Note: Don't feel like draining regular yogurt? Simply use 2 cups thick Greek-style yogurt; no need to drain it.

  3. While the yogurt is draining, put the bucket of your electric ice cream maker into the freezer to chill.

  4. Combine the drained yogurt with the remaining ingredients.

  5. Freeze in your ice cream maker according to the manufacturer's directions.

  6. Serve immediately, drizzled with a touch of vanilla extract, if desired. Or store in the freezer briefly before serving. This confection will freeze rock-hard within hours; if you need to make it ahead, be sure to leave time for it to soften before serving, about 15 minutes. Also, check out the tip at left for keeping frozen yogurt soft and scoopable in the freezer indefinitely.

Tips from our Bakers

  • Here's a nice variation: Sweeten with honey instead of corn syrup, and add 2 tablespoons spiced rum. The rum keeps the yogurt a bit softer in the freezer.
  • Drizzling frozen yogurt with just a touch of vanilla extract is the perfect final touch — especially when the extract includes some of the seeds, as our Vanilla Bean Crush does.
  • Is your frozen yogurt rock hard? Simply take it out of the freezer and let it sit at room temperature for 10 to 15 minutes; it'll soften up nicely. To keep frozen yogurt soft/scoopable in the freezer indefinitely, add 3 tablespoons alcohol — spiced rum, brandy, vodka — to the yogurt during the last couple of minutes of freezing. Remove from the ice cream maker, stir thoroughly, pack into an airtight container, and place in the freezer compartment of your refrigerator.